Interviews with Mark Knopfler

BF = Bill Flanagan, interviewer and writer of the book
"Written In My Soul"
MK = Mark Knopfler, lead guitarist and lead singer in Dire
Straits
BF: Let's run through some history: Your first album, Dire
Straits, released six months later in
America than in the rest of the world, was a smash, sold millions
of copies. The second album,
Communiqué, was already in the can when the first one came out.
In America it was often written off
as a rehash. During this time the band toured constantly. Then,
in early 1980, you pulled the band off
the road and made it clear you were calling the shots. You wrote
the making Movies album, went to
New York that summer to record it, and came back with a stronger
sound and a positive attitude. Is
any of that wrong?
MK: Not really. Just for the record, Communiqué did sell three
million copies. In a lot of countries it did
better than the first. Tha hang-up about Communiqué was an
American thing. But having said that, I still don't
think it was a very good record. Making Movies was closer to what
I like to do. On that record I was
determined I would not be immobilized by anything. I was going
on, to do what I knew I could do. I just kept
on working. I decided against being waylaid, to be a survivor
instead of casualty. That break gave me the
time to consider all that had happened and to express
it in terms of music. Retrospect's a really good thing. Time to
think and write it down. Some of those songs
were written during a period of turbulence. I wasn't felling good
or collected when I wrote "Solid Rock"; I
deliberately wrote and recorded that and "Expresso
Love" fast. I took more time to record "Romeo and
Juliet" because it took more time to write and demanded
special attention.
To crystallize: If you can turn negative energy into positive,
turn a dire straits situation, excuse the term, into
one that is positive, you're not going to go under, you're
creating. Like someone who could write a book in
prison. The songs are linked in that sense. It wasn't conscious,
but I see the Sultans, Les Bouys, the roller
skate girl, and Romeo all change disadvantage into advantage.
Rather than leave it thay make something with
it. I'm not advocating adverse circumstanses, but if they come
you have to create from it.
What have you been unable to write about?
Well, I've never felt moved to write about particularly obscene
people - I've gotten close, writing about
people who are very, very different from me like "Les
Boys" [Making Movies]. You take the part of
somebody else, you're just not that person. On "The Man's
Too Strong" [Brothers in Arms], I tried to do a
study in guilt and hatred and fear. On some levels, you can
almost see a Hess-like figure, in the depths of
Spandau. You might see somebody who's just not at peace with
himself. It's always interesting to me that any
kind of heavy censorship, like book burnings, has always failed
in the long run. That kind of suppression. I
was just trying to get in the mind of somebody who's lived his
life that way. There's nothing very heavy about
it, it's just an experiment in character and playwriting. That
song is absolutely not me. It's like Randy Newman
talking about being a closet gay truck driver.
I think if I was to sing "Private Dancer," "All
the men come in these places," the audience would know it
was
a character, they'd be able to make that adjustment. It's really
a song that a woman should sing, but to my
mind, a man should be able to just as easily, and if it's done
well, you should be able to make that adjustment.
If it's done properly, then part of the fun is to make that jump
- it's good for the imagination. I suppose there's
nearly always some connection. I mean, look at "Les
Boys." We're not gay, but they did cabaret and we do
loads of shows. We had done our turn when we saw them and I
thought, "God, what's the difference?"
The lead character in "Money for Nothing" is a guy who
works in the hardware department in a
telvision/custom kitchen/refrigerator/microwave appliance store.
He's singing the song. I wrote the song when
I was actually in the store. I borrowed a bit of paper and
started to write the song down in the store. I
wanted to use a lot of the language that the real guy actually
used when I heard him, because it was more
real. It just went better with the song, it was more muscular. I
actually used "little faggot," but there are a
couple of good "motherfuckers"in there. I wanted to do
a second version that way but I never had time. I'd
still love to be able to do it. Even if just the band had it,
because it would be the real version. I mean that is
the way people speak. I think people still get the general idea.
You can use other words that will suggest the
general feel.
It also has to do with the context in wich a song's received. If
we walk into a hardware store and hear
someone say, "Look at that motherfucker" it means
nothing to us, but if you hear it in a pop song . . .
If you hear it in New York it means nothing. If you're living in
Tallahassee then maybe it's a different thing.
There is no way that I would except people to receive all that in
the spirit in wich it was intended. They'd
probably think I was just being vulgar.
On the first two Dire Straits albums the narrator never spoke to
anyone. He was always standing in
the background watching the woman on the train, the Chinese
merchants, the Sultans of Swing. The
third album, Making Movies, still had songs like that, but also
had tracks such as "Expresso Love," in
wich the singer made direct contact. Do you think of yourself as
an outsider? Or do you find it easier
to write from that perspective?
"Brothers in Arms" is sung by a soldier who is dying on
the battlefield. You can't just write off the top of your
head; you have to dig deep to get those things. You have to
experience, if a thing is really going to be
realistic, if you're gonna try and get whatever you feel across.
So, in a sense you're an outsider, but you're
also digging inside to do it properly. I don't think you can get
away scot-free with these things; otherwise, it's
just not going to work. If you stay outside of these experiences,
they're just not going to translate to people.
That whole area of creation plays all kinds of tricks on the
writer. It can fool him into thinking that itäs easier
than it really is; it can fool him into thinking that it's harder
than it really is; it can fool him into thinking it's
working when it's not; it can fool him into thinking it's not
working when it is.
You might write something down and not really know. It might seem
that there's logic to it, there's a flow to it,
there's some kind of reason to it, there was some kind of cause
that's coming out in terms of this effect. But
the reasons might make themselves more clear to you afterwards.
You could be having a fairly clear vision,
but there could be some mechanism, wich for a good reason gets in
the way of that. Perhaps you're getting
more involved in the finer technical points of rhyme. So, it's a
weird business, all that.
The thing has to have a whole, harmonic balance. You try to
create something that's going to work on a
number levels: it's useful, it's functional, it's beautiful, it
makes a point, it has its own reality. And it's based
always on music you like to play. I'm not saying that everything
is a crisis, I'm just saying that everwhere there
are choices - at every level of the game. Doing a movie score or
making a record there's so many choices, so
many possibilities. You talk about being an outsider. Well, you
try standing outside while being inside, too.
It's important to be able to be outside, dispassionate. You do
have to stand back and look at what you're
painting. You can't just enter into the depths of this thing and
have bits of paint flying all over the place. You
have to look at what you're making.
The precision that you bring to your work at every level, and how
careful you are of choices, stands in direct
contrast to some of the people you've worked with - Bob Dylan and
Van Morrison - who do in fact seem to
jump in there with the paint flying.
Well, s lot of oaint flies around me as well. It's just that
perhaps the thing gets sculpted a bit more.
You're so much the ringleader of your own circus, is it tough for
you to join somebody else's? When
you're recording with Bob Dylan, is it tough for you to have to
defer to him, when you have your own
vision of how this record can be perfect?
I don't believe in perfect, I just don't believe that. There's so
many ways to do any song, perfection's just a
cloud in the air. People say I'm a perfectionist and all of that.
It's just not so.
I think it's fair to say that you have great self-confidence.
Well, I have the self-confidence to go gaily steaming off in
completely the wrong direction. (Laughs.) Yes,
that's the kind of man I am. As far as music goes, it's very easy
for things to get way out of hand with me, just
because I've got the confidence. "This is the way it
is!" I'm very glad that I'm continually outting myself in
situations where it's being made absolutely obvious that the
directions wich I feel like charging off in aren't the
right directions at all.
Did you feel when you were a kid like you'd live in America
someday?
Yeah. I think just because of music. It wasn't because of
Hollywood. It was because of rock & roll music,
more than anything. I've always felt an affinity with America,
Americans. It's because America's made up of
Everyman - in some ways I feel as though I'm made up of a little
bit of Everyman, too. I feel I have things in
common with almost anywhere I am. The only time I've felt really,
really at odds with all the people around
me was when I've been anywhere near a mob. Where there's brute
ignorance in a mass of people, like a
lynch mob mentality, I always feel very separate. Pictures I've
seen in magazines of people getting killed by
soldiers or anything like that. I played all the war games as a
kid and nobody played them with more intense
seriousness than I did, with more enjoyment. I was really into
it. I loved to play them. Having grown up,
there's something about a mob of people that worries me, that
makes me really feel like an outsider. I get as
angry as anybody else does when an old lady's beaten up or
murdered, I get very mad and start saying,
"We've gone soft in the head, we're letting these guys out
of jail," and I probably sound a bit reactionary. But
I remember once going to a football match when the guys like to
fight one another, and I remember feeling so
utterly separate from this energy. Maybe they were the kind of
kids who were made to feel like they were
rejects and this was their time to get rid of that energy, to
sream blue murder and maybe get into a fight. That
always worried me. I'm used to it because I grew up in Glasgow
and Newcastle and got into plenty of fights.
I learned how to fight there. But I still fear it terribly. I'm
still distressed that there are so many people who
see quite content to follow that as a way of life. They're not
adverse to standing on a corner with a broken
bottle in their hand, waving it in somebody's face. It seems that
it's acceptable to them that violence is part of
our lives. It's acceptable that Bernhard Goetz can talk about the
need for people to walk around with guns.
Or that it's perfectly alright to send armies into places to
bang, bang, shoot 'em up. Stick a bayonet in his ass.
What the hell is that? My grandfathers were probably fightin in
the British Army and the German Army. They
probably tried to kill each other and if they had, that would
have been that. There would be no strumming.
DO YOU THINK THERE'S
an identifiable British sound to Dire Straits?
I don't really think of Dire Straits as a sound, you know. It.
just depends on the song, and the stuff we're
doing is so varied. I don't think of sounds as being American or
English or Japanese or German. That doesn't
mean anything; it's all just music. It's either good music or bad
music, and good music, to me, is the stuff that's
got a bit of soul. The other stuff I'm not really interested in.
For Local Hero, did you reach back for some Celtic influences you
heard when you were growing up?
Well, I was born in Scotland and spent the first six years of my
life there. Then I went to Newcastle-On-Tyne
in northeast England, close to Scotland. So I heard a lot of that
music, and of course it's still very strong. In
fact, what are the Everly Brothers but that Celtic thing? You can
hear the Celtic influence in a lot of country
music as well as in people like Gerry Rafferty [of "Baker
Street" fame] - that Celtic drone. I had to get even
closer still with Cal, which is set in Ireland. For that, I used
a fair amount of uillean pipes played by Sean
O'Flynn, who's maybe the best exponent of that. Lately, I've
become friendly with an Irish singer called Paul
Brady, who plays whistle on Cal.
Was rock and roll the first music you ever played?
Yes. I heard my uncle Kingsley playing boogie woogie on the piano
when I was about eight or nine, and I
thought that those three chords were the most magnificent things
in the world - still do. The first records I
made my mom buy were Lonnie Donegan skiffle records. That was
before I was 10 years old. I had to wait
until I was 15 before I got a guitar, because my old man wanted
me to appreciate it when I got it. It was a
red Hofner V-2, I think they called it. Cost 50 quid. It was
Strat-shaped, and it had to be red.
American-made guitars were pretty scarce in England in the early
‘60s.
Yeah. A Strat was a thing of wonder. When I was 14or 15, the
Shadows were a big influence, and they had
the first Strats that came to England. Cliff Richard brought them
back for them. Hank Marvin played lead on
a Strat, and Bruce Welch played Tele rhythm.
Were you also influenced by American instrumental bands from the
late ‘5Os and early ‘6Os?
Oh, yes. I went up the street to a little pal of mine and made
him play me ,,Because They're Young" [by
Duane Eddy] 49 times. I could spend the whole day listening to
that: the twang. Do you remember the
Fireballs? I have one Fireballs single with ,,Quite A Party"
on one side and ,,Gunshot" on the other. I played
that 4,900 times. Completely and utterly in love with it. Then
you'd grow up into Radio Luxembourg, and
you'd sit up talking to your older sister. She talks about her
boyfriends, and you listen to Ben E. King's
,,Spanish Harlem" or ,,Hey, Baby" by Bruce Channel -
stuff like that.
Were you also into rockabilly?
Early Elvis, of course, and one of the biggest of all was the
Everly Brothers - with Chet Atkins on guitar; but
of course, I didn't know that, and they didn't put their names on
records then. But he's probably the greatest
of all. Then there was Ricky Nelson - a record called ,,Just A
Little Too Much," which doesn't get a lot of
exposure-and I didn't know then that that was James Burton on
guitar. The sound on those records-just listen
to the backing on ,,Hello, Mary Lou" - is astonishingly
great. Jerry Lee Lewis was another complete genius.
A lot of English rock guitarists got their start playing
,,trad" razz, Dixieland. Were you involved in
that at all?
No, the only thing young kids were really exposed to were the
occasional novelty pop singles like ,,Midnight
In Moscow" by [trumpeter] Kenny Ball or ,,Stranger On The
Shore" by [clarinetist] Acker Bilk. Later on, I
got into it some. Everything went in stages. After I'd gotten the
solidbody Hofner, I didn't have the nerve to
ask my dad for an amplifier - it cost so much - so I had to
borrow a friend's acoustic guitar. All the time I
wanted to play rock and roll, I got forced into playing sort of
folk joints. Of course, that was very good,
because I learned how to fingerpick. The first time I heard a 4/4
claw-hammer picking pattern, I fell totally in
love with that. So things were progressing on a number of fronts.
Later, I got into National steel-body guitars
from a guy in Leeds called Steve Phillips, who also builds
beautiful guitars. I got involved in all kinds of slide
playing and ragtime, country blues, jugband, and even western
swing.
When you got into different styles, how studied was your
approach?
Not studied at all. I was just trying to absorb the spirit of the
thing, rather than take an academic approach.
I've never had a guitar lesson. I'm not proud of it particularly,
but it's just the way I seem to do it. It's not the
best way. I don't recommend it to all your readers.
Considering the enormous impact the Beatles had on American
groups, they must have been an even
bigger influence on a young musician like yourself growing up in
England
Oh, huge! ,,Please, Please Me" was one of the first records
that I bought. It's funny now, because while I've
been working with Aztec Camera at Ayre Studio [in London], I've
been playing Asteroids about every other
day with Paul McCartney. It's slightly strange to think, ,,Oh,
that's him"[laughs]. But I also liked the Rolling
Stones, and I absolutely loved the Kinks. I got into trouble for
writing Le Kinks on notebooks and desks in
school. I loved songs like ,,Where Have All the Good Times
Gone," ,,Waterloo Sunset, and ,,You Really
Got Me." I enjoyed that period, and then a few years later,
when I was 18or 19, I got into a lot of the
American bands, like the Doors, and some of the English bands
that didn't necessarily make it as big, such as
Head, Hands & Feet [with Albert Lee]. I never really got into
deep record collecting, because I was always
moving around and was too impoverished.
When did you get into R&B guitar players?
When I was listening to Elvis and the Everlys, I suppose. Then
shortly before Dire Straits, I was playing a
Gibson Les Paul Special in a rockabilly / R&B band in London.
When I heard B.B. King, at age 16, that was
another big turning point, because I was really struck with the
relationship between the guitar and the voice
and the whole bending thing, the way it sounded. Later, when I
was 20 or 21, I remember hearing Lonnie
Johnson with Eddie Lang - the Blue Guitars album [EMI, PCM 7019].
Then I realized that there was a
connection, and I read an interview with B.B. King saying that
Lonnie Johnson had been a big influence on
him. It's great to make these little connections and see how they
do line up.
Bob Dylan is probably the most obvious influence on your singing
and writing.
I was hugely influenced by him about the age of 14 or 15, going
‘round to girls' houses, drinking 75 cups of
coffee, smoking 90 cigarettes, and listening to Blonde On Blonde
[Columbia, CS2-841] 120 times. I heard
Bob Dylan from the very beginning, the ,,Hard Rain" days,
and went with him all the way up, and I'm still with
him. I still think he's great. Blood On The Tracks [Columbia,
HC-43235] is one of my favorite records, with
,,Tangled Up In Blue." On the last record [Infidels], to
hear the first lines of "I And I," that's enough to
make
anybody who writes songs want to retire. It's stunning. Bob's
musical ability is limited, in terms of being able
to play a guitar or a piano. It's rudimentary, but it doesn't
affect his variety, his sense of melody, his singing.
It's all there. In fact, some of the things he plays on piano
while he's singing are lovely, even though they're
rudimentary. That all demonstrates the fact that you don't have
to be a great technician. It's the same old
story: If something is played with soul, that's what's important.
My favorite records, by and large, aren't
wonderful technical achievements, with the exception perhaps of
people like Chet Atkins. But generally
speaking, all you've got to do is listen to a Howlin' Wolf album
- that's just soul.
Along with the impact Dylan had on you, were you also influenced
much by the Band, in particular
Robbie Robertson's guitar playing?
No, I don't think so. Not really.
Were there any specific guitar influences that made your style
take the form it did?
I don't know.
Some of your playing is reminiscent of J.J. Cale's.
Oh, of course, yeah. I listened to a lot of J.J. Cale around the
time my style was developing. He's great. I'd
love to meet him. He's very, very special to me.
Another guitarist to whom you bear a remarkable similarity is
Richard Thompson.
Well, I haven't really heard much of Richard Thompson's stuff. I
saw him play live years ago with his
then-wife [Linda Thompson] and enjoyed it very much. But I've
only listened to one of his records.Around
the time Dire Straits was starting, we were all in this house,
and John [Illsley] hadone of his records. I haven't
really kept up with him, but I mean to do something about that.
We've both done folk music and things, so
there's probably quite a lot of common ground. I think I was
probably more into the blues, while he was
doing Fairport Convention.
But like Thompson, you don’t at all resemble the stereotypical
blues-based lead guitarist rattling off
pentatonic licks.
You mean down-da-da-da, down-da-da-da, down-da-da-da? Have you
heard that Pretenders single
[,,Middle Of The Road," Learning To Crawl, Sire, 1-23980]?
Right, I don't do that [laughs].
On Slow Train Coming, on the other hand, you didn‘t play the
sorts of things you‘re known for with
Dire Straits. It’s very bluesy, a la Albert King.
I was asked to do that. [Producer] Jerry Wexler said, ,,Try for a
gut-bucket style of thing." So I borrowed a
Gibson ES-335 that somebody down there had, and off we went.
On Infidels, whose idea was it to have Mick Taylor on guitar?
Bob decided on the whole band, although I did suggest that Alan
[Clarke] be there, because we'd been in the
room doing Local Hero and had sort of a working thing going on
there. And I suggested the engineer, Neill
Dorfsman, who did Love Over Gold and Local Hero. We were like a
three-man team at that point. Sly
Dunbar and Robbie Shakespeare [reggae's top studio drummer and
bassist, respectively] were Bob's ideas,
as well as Mick Taylor. I suggested Billy Gibbons, but I don't
think Bob had heard of ZZ Top. It would have
been great to have done that with Billy. My roughs are different
from the final record. Bob mixed it, because I
had to go on tour in Germany with Dire Straits. I think he
changed some things. I've only heard the album
once.
Was it difficult producing Dylan?
Yeah. You see people working in different ways, and it's good for
you. You have to learn to adapt to the
way different people work. Yes, it was strange at times with Bob.
One of the great parts about production is
that it demonstrates to you that you have to be flexible. Each
song has its own secret that's different from
another song, and each has its own life. Sometimes it has to be
teased out, whereas other times it might come
fast. There are no laws about songwriting or producing. It
depends on what you're doing, not just who you're
doing. You have to be sensitive and flexible, and it's fun. I'd
say I was more disciplined. But I think Bob is
much more disciplined as a writer of lyrics, as a poet. He's an
absolute genius. As a singer - absolute genius.
But musically, I think it’s a lot more basic. The music just
tends to be a vehicle for that poetry.
When you're playing on someone else's record, what sort of
directions do you usually get from the
artist or the producer?
In 99% of the cases, almost none. It’s always very nice.
What do you want to know about the song you’re playing on?
I want to know what the lyric is, what the song is about. I like
to talk to the lyric to a certain extent. That's
important to me. What was funny and kind of nice about doing
Bryan Ferry's stuff is that Bryan works
backwards from the way I work. He creates these very nice
sounding, very simple grooves, and they seem to
instigate the lyric. The lyrics come last which is great, just
fine. But, you know, I would say to Bryan, ,,What
do you think this is going to be about? A dragonfly. Oh."
And that can create tension or whatever, too.
Do you usually get called to do a session because someone is
after your specific sound?
It varies. It's usually all-around guitar playing. A lot of the
things that I do on session don't relate to the Dire
Straits sound, if there is such a thing. I might be just playing
my Gibson Chet Atkins solidbody classical or a
National, maybe just doing a part or something.
You don’t feel as though you’ve been stereotyped for your
identifiable sound and lead approach?
To me, that's never seemed to be limiting in terms of sessions. I
like to play a lot of different styles of things
on sessions. On Tina Turner's new album, she recorded a song I
wrote called ,,Private Dancer," and she got
the whole Dire Straits band to play on it, but I was busy doing
the Bryan Ferry sessions. So she got Jeff
Beck to play the second ugliest guitar solo you've ever heard on
it.
What are the advantages and disadvantages to doing sessions or
working on film scores as opposed
to playing in a band?
Oh, it's all just advantages. It all makes you bigger. It's a
challenge. I look at something like Cal where I did
all the music cues, and I didn't think I could do it at first.
But I just started at the beginning and staggered
through it from one piece to the next until it was finished. It's
a finely-tuned film, and the slightest thing you
add or subtract really affects what's going on. It's very
exacting. There are a lot of decisions to be made. It's
part of a picture, but at the same time you want the music to
stand up on its own. I don't like soundtrack
albums that have one song and the rest is all filler.
On a film score, do you work along with the director?
Yes. For instance, with Cal, I made sure that Pat O'Connor, the
director, was in the studio almost every day.
I'd just drag him in there. That's another reason I like film
work: You're trying to do something for somebody
else, and you're cooperating. It's less selfish in a way than
this egomaniac thing of Singer/ Songwriter Does
Own Record. It's nice to be a part of a bigger thing.
Do you think you’d ever put out a solo album not connected with
a film or with Dire Straits?
I feel that with the band there's enough for all that expression.
But I would like to make some little records for
different kinds of things - maybe built around the guitar or
whatever. And I love to do sessions. I get enough
to do without feeling frustrated about not doing solo records.
The film stuff gives me an Opportunity to do all
that. To have musicians like [saxophonist] Mike Brecker and
[vibist] Mike Mainieri or [bassist] Tony Levin
play on your music is wonderful. Words can't express it.
Apart from sessions and Dire Straits, do you get a chance to sit
in with other musicians on a regular
basis?
A little bit, but not as much as I'd like to. But that's just
because of the demands of the cycle of events of the
group, the production stuff, and the films. I love to play with
other people. I think musicians should and,
generally speaking, do intermingle a lot. I'm totally in favor of
that. I've got a little project in the back of me
mind that Mike Mainieri has been asking me about. We sort of
talked about putting some people together
and making music. It's all just a question of time. I'd love to
have 60-hour days.
Has your composing for Dire Straits been influenced much by movie
soundtracks? A lot of your songs
have a feel somewhat like The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly.
Yes, that's Ennio Morricone. He's done The Good, The Bad, And The
Ugly, Fistful Of Dollars things like
1900. Yes, he's a big influence.
Do you have any particularly strong literary influences in your
songwriting?
Lots and lots. That was my subject at university, and I taught
English for a while. There's too many to name:
Shakespeare, a lot of American writers, such as Raymond Chandler,
metaphysical poets.
Do you find that certain keys or chord progressions give pieces a
more majestic quality?
Yeah, I like certain keys more and more. I've been doing a lot of
stuff in F and D minor. ,,Down To The
Waterline" [Dire Straits] is B minor, which is a nice key as
well.
Is that the Ennio Morricone influence coming through?
Probably, yes. That slightly comic, melodramatic thing. I call it
,,spaghetti music. ,, Things like ,,Private
Investigations" [Love Over Gold] are almost tongue-in-cheek
deliberately exaggerated.
Your guitar playing seems fairly delicate, yet there are a lot of
dynamics, a lot of driving rhythms in
your music.
Thank you. I like arranging other people's instruments, and
working with the way verses go into choruses. I
like dynamics and things to be a little bit dramatic. I work with
every aspect of the whole thing: the bass, the
piano, when a bass drum is hit, every highhat beat. Certain
pieces just go, but with other pieces I like to get
into everything that goes on.
On a studio album, how much overdubbing do you do?
We end up keeping quite a lot of the live takes, actually. Love
Over Gold was a heavily worked on record.
Too much attention was paid to that, I think, in a lot of
respects. But it was interesting to have done it that
way. I don't think I'd like to do another record that was so
heavily produced, though.
Do you eve play rhythm guitar yourself?
Oh, I love to. I like to have two rhythm guitars on most pieces
anyway.
Do you also instruct or direct the other rhythm guitarist’s
part?
Pretty much, usually. The bass and drums as well.
So you write the arrangement as well as the song itself?
Pretty much, but people always bring their own little bits and
pieces to it. Sometimes they bring the entire
thing, and that's even greater. Every musician will come up with
things that only he could come up with, and I
like to use those things. Hal [Lindes] often comes up with
different voicings than I would have had in mind.
Does that change the mood of the song?
It can, yes.
You have a very vocal-like guitar style, but it’s not at all
like the B. B. King style you mentioned
earlier.
Part of the difference, I suppose, would be chucking away the
pick when I was evolving my own style. Style,
I find, is always impossible to define, but it's easy to
recognize.
What made you start playing lead with your bare fingers?
It just started to happen. I remember sitting in a house in
London - starving to death at the time - playing a
cheap Japanese acoustic with really light electric guitar strings
on it. I knew then that it was on a turn, it was
developing. I was doing things with my fingers that I couldn't do
with a pick-really fast things and what have
you. I still love to play with a pick, and sometimes you have to
record certain parts or songs with a pick - for
instance, ,,Expresso Love" [Making Movies]. But it's
interesting that now I'm not nearly as comfortable with
a pick as I am with my fingers.
Did you go through different stages of developing techniques and
experimenting with fingerpicks?
Yes. I went through thumbpicks and even steel fingerpicks with
the Nationals, and I dispensed with them. It's
a bit of a disadvantage without them sometimes, because a
thumbpick is just great for that chunk thing that
Chet Atkins can do so brilliantly.
What does your picking technique consist of now?
It's the thumb and first two fingers, and I tend to anchor with
the back or my hand and my other two fingers,
so it's a solid base.
Do you pick with your fingernails or with the meat of your
fingertips?
It's really from skin, but sometimes the nail will catch. You can
use the nail to snap it. A lot of times, I’ll hit a
note with the thumb and second finger together, so it might seem
as though I'm pinching the string, squeezing
it. The second finger hits it first I think, behind the thumb, so
you can get a real physicality with a note.
Is your tone a product of the type of guitar you play, or is it a
result of your picking technique?
I think it's a combination. I like to play all kinds of guitars,
not just Strats, but I wasn't getting the sound I
really wanted until I got a Stratocaster. It was about a 61 with
a rosewood neck. I like rosewood necks a lot,
even though I end up playing a lot of maple necks. I very rarely
use a Fender Strat these days; it's usually a
Schecter instead, which is a more powerful guitar.
Your old Fender Strat used to have the 3-way toggle switch taped
so that it would stop in the position
between the middle and rear pickups. why didn't you just get a
5-position switch to achieve the same
pickup combination?
I liked the 3-way switch better than the 5-position; it had a
better sound. But I kept knocking it out. I have a
5-position switch on the Strat now. The roadies are always
pulling bits out and sticking things in.
Why did you switch from your Fender to a Strat-style Schecter?
I didn't want to keep flogging a Strat around the world, getting
it smashed
pieces. Same thing with my beautiful Telecaster that David
[Knopfler] used to play rhythm on in the band. It's
a double-bound sunburst Custom Tele, about a ’67 or ‘68, and
I'm not inclined to have it smashed to bits.
The Schecter is beautifully made and very strong.
Does it weigh a lot more than the Fender?
Yeah, the Schecters do tend to weigh a lot more. Probably the
best electric I ever had was a Schecter that I
used on Making Movies, but it was stolen. John Suhr, at Rudy's
Music Stop in New York City, has worked
on all my guitars, and so does Jack Sonni from the same shop. I
got John to come to the studio all the way
through the Dylan sessions [for Infidels], just to work on all
the guitars. He screens different pickups and
installs them. John does the best work I've ever seen - brilliant
fretjobs and what have you.
Are your guitars heavily modified?
Not really. One Schecter has Seymour Duncan Vintage pickups, and
another red one has heavier Seymour
Strat pickups in it.
Have you amassed a very sizable instrument collection?
No, I haven't. For instance, I still haven't got a flat-top
wooden acoustic, because I've never found one that
was as good as the two best flat tops I ever played. One was a
David Russell Young guitar that Steve Khan
lent me, which was absolutely stunning. The other was a
hand-built Greco that Rudy [Pensa, of Rudy's Music
Stop] lent me. I used the David Russell Young on Love Over Gold,
and the Greco on Infidels. When I got
my Ovation Adamases, I started using them straight away on Slow
Train Coming and Local Hero. For the
Aztec Camera thing, I borrowed a couple of old Martins from Eric
Clapton, because they'd been using
Ovations, and you just can't get the personality out of them.
They've also been using my new red Schecter
Tele [see cover], which is one of the best sounding electric
guitars I've ever had.
So on Dire Straits albums you play borrowed acoustics?
I have some Ovations, but no wooden flat-tops. Hal has a Martin,
and my Adamas guitars-a 6- and a
12-string have seen quite a bit of recording. One of my favorite
guitars is the Gibson Chet Atkins solidbody
classical, which has been on a lot of sessions since I got it.
It's a beautifully made thing. I use it onstage, too,
because you can get really loud with the thing. The action is
low, so it tries to get the best of both worlds. By
and large, I think it succeeds. It's a lot of fun to play. I used
it on the Bryan Ferry sessions [as yet
unreleased], some sessions with Phil Everly, and on the film
scores I just did.
When you record with an Ovation, do you play it through an amp?
It sounds great direct. I might have an amp out in the studio
with a microphone on it, too. On Local Hero,
we sent the Adamas direct quite a lot.
Do you ever work out solos ahead of time on a session?
No, not really. Sometimes it might break down in the middle, and
then you figure out which way it should go,
and punch it in. Hut generally speaking, it's pretty
rough-and-ready. I'll often play three passes, record them
all, and then make something by stitching them together.
You usually stay pretty close to the song's melody or play a
countermelody, instead of working off
licks and patterns.
Well, it doesn't go down-da-da-da, down-da-da-da [laughs].
Judging by the live album, you’ve recently begun taking more
extended solos.
I started writing other sections for songs like ,,In The
West," instead of that sort of skeletal Communiqué
approach. With the keyboards coming into the band, I started
writing new sections and was inspired to build
things up a bit, trying to get the full possibilities of the song
out, instead of the more linear approach that
marked the earlier sound of Dire Straits.
Why did you decide to come out with live a LP at this point?
Several reasons. I wanted to have a record of the band at that
certain stage. Second, we played to about
three-quarters of a million people on the last tour, and a lot of
them found their way into our dressing room.
One of the major things the fans would ask for was a live record.
Also, I wanted to see if we could do a
genuine live album without tampering with the multitrack in any
way - which we managed to do.
On most supposedly live albums, they’ve overdubbed.
Everything. I got to play an awful lot of pool during that
record, because the engineer was doing a lot of the
mixing, so I was just upstairs playing pool. It wasn't very
taxing.
Why did Dire Straits put out a four-song EP after Love Over Gold,
rather than a complete album?
Well, the EP was actually a reaction against the album. After
doing something where you spend a lot of
care-and doing ,,Private Investigations" about 20,000 times
- then all you want to do, basically, is play
,,Bebop-A-Lula."
Do you vary your amps and settings much in the studio?
We just take potluck and go. For stage, I have two amps set up
for different things. They're Boogies with
Marshall cabinets. One's set lower, and I put the National
through that, and you have to graphic [EQ] pretty
heavily for that onstage. It's a metal-body with palm trees and
canoes on it [a l4 fret Style 0 from the 1930s].
What about effects? There's an interesting fast echo on
,,Waterline" [Dire Straits].
I have no idea what that was. Rhett Davies was the engineer on
that record, and he's in love with Roland
Chorus Ensembles, so it might well have been that. I actually use
a Roland onstage. Most of my effects are
echoes. I have a Delta Lab that I like very much, too.
Do you prefer a certain brand and gauge of strings?
They're called Dean Markley Custom Lights. I'd have to check the
gauges [high to low, .009, 011, 015, 026,
036, 046]
Is there a pattern to your creative process when you write a
song?
No, there's no formula, no law. I'm lazy [laughs]. One song might
come quickly, and another might take
hundreds of hours over a long period of time with varying amounts
of inebriation.
What's the most inebriated song you ever wrote?
,,Once Upon A Time In The West" [Communiqué] was one of
them. I was watching the film on TV in a
slightly altered state.
Do you use a multitrack cassette recorder to keep track of ideas
and come up with arrangements?
No, I should. I don't even use a tape recorder. I just write
things down in a book. A lot of ideas come
around, and I've forgotten them in the morning. Sometimes I
figure, ,,Well, if I wake up and can still
remember it, then it's worth remembering."
Do you just jam on guitar to come up with melodies and changes?
Yes, for hours and hours. And then for more hours. I can play by
myself quite happily for days. Sometimes I
sit down at the piano and hit the keys, make shapes, but I’m
not what you'd call a player. I'm not what I'd
call a proper musician on the guitar. I feel as though I'm a
student who's not going to school. I've been
working from the Mickey Baker book [Jazz And Hot Guitar, Book I]
to get some extra chords. I love to
learn a new chord and find out what it means, and use it in what
I write. I'm developing slowly that way.
Have the outside projects made it difficult to keep to a schedule
with Dire Straits?
Dire Straits' schedule is dictated partly by whether or not I've
written any songs, and also by how many other
things I want to do. If I did all the things I get asked to do,
then there would be no time for Dire Straits at all.
So to a certain extent, it does affect the band. The band would
probably be working much more if I weren't
doing anything else. But then life would be extremely dull and
tedious, wouldn't it?
Is there anything else you'd like to add?
Just this [picking up his red Schecter]: down-da-da-da,
down-da-da-da, down-da-da-da...
On earlier records you played slide on your National. Did you use
an open tuning on, say ,,Water Of
Love"?
Yeah. G tuning-D, G, D, G, B, D - capoed somewhere. I could
always do a lot more with it than with the E
tuning.
On which finger do you wear your slide?
A hundred years ago, I started with the third - doing Elmore
James, straight off, no problem. It just felt more
comfortable. When I realized I needed more fingers to do other
things, the slide went on the little finger.
Have you always had an affinity for country blues?
Yeah. I didn't actually study it the way I studied literature at
the university. I was never a Stefan Grossman
aficionado or anything, because I always rejected the academic
approach to country blues. I’d listen, not
necessarily to imitate the music, but to get off on lt. If you
stay too stuck in something old, you just end up
being a guy with leather elbow pads on his sport jacket who turns
up with a National guitar and plays these
academically correct country blues tunes, imitations of Gary
Davis or something. So what? Enjoy the music,
get the attitude and spirit out of it, and move on. It's not
about making a religion of these people. Don't build
a shrine.
Do you remember a particular moment when you discovered what the
world would later call the
,,Knopfler sound"?
Yeah, I suppose so. I was sleeping on the floor in somebody's
apartment. They had a cheap imitation of a
Gibson Dove acoustic with unbelievably light strings. It was like
playing an electric guitar, but there was a little
bit of sound to it. You couldn't really strum or bash it, so I
had to fingerpick. As I was flying around this
guitar, I realized I was doing things with my fingers that I
could do with a pick and also some other things that
I wouldn’t be able to do with a pick. Playing with your fingers
has something to do with immediacy and soul.
You are absolutely in touch with what is going on. And that can
lead to other things too. On the electric, I
developed the sound a bit further with a volume pedal.
Really? Most would assume you were manipulating your Strat’s
volume knob to get that crying sound.
Just a simple Ernie Ball pedal. It gives you more of a speaking
voice, something that approximates a steel
guitar. I always wanted that. I can’t sing, so the guitar
becomes a voice in many ways. You are not looking at
Bonnie Raitt here.
Are you trying to minimize attack?
That’s more like a voice coming in, isn’t it? But sometimes
I’ll make a meal of the attack: With my thumb and
fingers I’ll do a little flurry – pa-ta-dam. I’m just
interested in attack as lack of attack.
How exactly do you create that flurry? Do you snag the strings
with your index finger and then follow
through with your thumb?
Well, yes, it’s the same as the boogie rhythm. In other words,
the fingers do a pickup before the downbeat.
The downbeat is with the thumb. This applies to rhythm playing
– which is my greates joy – as well as solo
playing. You anticipate the downbeat with a pickup, a brush from
either on or two fingers. A flamenco
guitarist will swirl the fingers an then – wham – hit the
downbeat. It’s a cheapened, mediocre version of that.
How does one develop a signature voice?
It’s not going to happen by buying a videocassette tape that
shows you how to play like some guy in a heavy
metal band. You'd be much better off listening to Howlin' Wolf
and then taking it nice and slow from there.
You're exploring new sounds. For example, "On Euery
Street" has a twangy line that
sounds flatpicked.
Yeah, I used a pick for that. I played an old [Gibson] Super 400
with Alnico pickups through a [Fender]
Vibrolux with the tremolo on. That's genre. You've got to love
all that crap, haven't you? [Laughs]
In a big way. How do you get that warm, throaty lead tone in
"You And Your Friend"?
My Les Paul has a little alteration [see Love Over Gear]. You can
pull a pot up and get a slightly
out-of-phase sound. Then you just back one of the levels down a
little bit to where it becomes this voice. I
tried to get that on ,,Brothers In Arms" but it didn't
please [engineer] Neil Dorfsman at the time we were
doing it. I always liked that sound; with a Les Paul it's a
beautiful thing.
What acoustic did you use on ,Iron Hand"?
That was an old [Gibson] J-45. I just sang and played. I wasn't
feeling too well.
How about that low-key, smoky tone in "Fade To Black"?
The Super 400 again. Those Alnicos are great. If Gibson could
find a way to make those pickups once more,
they should.
It's a real jazz/blues mood - shades of Django or Kenny Burrell.
Originally it was a Rolling Stones kind of thing. That wasn't
making me happy, so I changed the chords right
around and put the Super 400 on. Everybody just played, and I
sang and played. We never changed the
vocal, the guitar, anything. That's an untouched recording.
Wow. These days, that's pretty radical.
You're not going to get recordings that capture the spirit of the
moment [snaps fingers] unless you've got
confidence, knowledge, and belief. It's important to have people
on your side, a band who can follow what's
going on. They don't have to be the world's greatest players, but
if you're going to embark on a recording like
that, I would heartily suggest that you get a great drummer. One
of the reasons why I loved making this album
so much was because of [drummer] Jeff Porcaro. He's an artist.
Did you cut many tracks live?
,,Iron Hand," ,,Fade To Black," ,,Calling Elvis" -
there's a bunch of stuff on this record that just happened.
Everybody is just playing. Who's recording like that now? It's
not an engineer's dream, but more people
should record live if they can.
You're not afraid to mix styles.
Even on the straight things - a song like ,,How Long," for
instance - I like to put something in that they
wouldn't allow on country radio. A heavy distorted, very, very
loud guitar on a country song: Rock and roll
won't play it, country won't play it, but that's the music I
really like. That's where I'm at. I like working around
that delicious place where country meets blues, playing with the
third or the absence of the third. It's a highly
stimulating pre-orgasmic area [grins].
Do you have a home studio?
Yeah, in London. I don't know if it passes for a real studio. I
did a Notting Hillbillies record [Missing. ..
Presumed Having A Good Time and most of the Chet record [Neck And
Neck] there. You've got to be
quite careful - the door doesn't close. You can hear motorcycles
and builders and stuff.
When you're off the road and not working on an album or a film
score, do you ever practice?
Well, songwriting becomes practicing becomes songwriting becomes
practicing.
But I hear an evolution in your playing. More chromatic notes.
Diminished runs.
You pick up licks here and there to increase your vocabulary.
So you advocate a less structured, more oblique approach to
learning?
I say strange things that most teachers would never say. Watch
television with the sound off and play
something. Fall asleep while playing.
Do you do that much?
Oh yeah, ever since the beginning. I'll fall asleep playing and
my fingers will just be flying about.
Describe your songwriting process.
I write everything on an acoustic. I usually don't have an
electric at home. I'm dead lazy and I'm no good with
tape recorders or anything, so I just stick some words down in a
notebook and try to remember the music.
Got any writing tips?
On this last little break during the tour, I had a capo on the
3rd fret of my acoustic; it changed everything
completely I was writing different stuff and an awful lot of
stuff because of this change. So if you're in a rut,
you might want to change your format. For instance, I originally
wrote ,,Sultans Of Swing" on my National
steel guitar, open tuned. Same lyrics, but a different tune.
Since I can't remember it, it was completely
unremarkable [laughs]. When I got the Strat and plugged into an
old Vibrolux, it became something else.
So new tools can breed new ideas.
Yeah. Sometimes a change is as good as a rest Tune your guitar to
a chord and you'll write something
different. Stick a capo on it, you might write something else.
Ever try fingerpicks?
I dispensed with thumbpicks and fingerpicks a long time ago. A
fingerpick doesn't give you a down blast if
you want one. And the thumbpick separates your thumb from your
fingers. Chet uses a thumbpick, so his
bass is always clearer and much louder than mine. And he
cultivates his nails, so he gets more level all round.
You learn these things: Falling asleep on holiday on this last
break, I discovered that the [third and fourth
finger] anchor I use actually mutes the acoustic.
Are you practicing now without it?
Yeah, I'm playing more fingers off. Anchors aweigh! With an
acoustic it sounds so much better This is
elementary stuff, but it took me 20 years to find out.
Do you see any drawbacks to playing fingerstyle?
Because I'm playing with my fingers, I need good amplification.
The best amplifiers are picks. As soon as you
lose the pick, you lose a lot of level. It changes the tone and,
in terms of genre, it changes the legitimacy of
what you do. So if I'm playing a straight blues or something with
my fingers on an electric guitar, I have to
think slightly differently. On something like ,,Love You Too
Much," I might have to work a little bit harder to
be legit, whereas if I used a pick it would be fine. But I could
never keep picks anyway, so I just play the
way I do and dial up the right sound on the Soldano amp.
What other acoustics do you own?
I recently bought a Taylor that I like a lot. My favorite
acoustics are made by [Notting Hillbillies member]
Steve Phillips. I have two. They're the best I've ever played. He
only made a few; unfortunately, one was
destroyed. He tried to approximate a ‘30s Martin, basically
Where do you find inspiration?
Listening to old music is great. You have to know old stuff - get
right back into it, know it, feel it. It's no good
these heavy metal bands putting slides on their fingers and
picking up Nationals and pretending they know
how to do that stuff as part of their shtick. It's just woeful.
Having said that, I'm very critical of myself
because I don't practice electric, which I should really do. I
still get myself in knots with the band, and I'll
stand there and think, ,,What the hell am I going to do
now?" But that's part of the fun of playing live. And I
do intend to practice; I should and I will.
What constitutes "old music"?
If you think going back means Led Zeppelin, have another think!
You have to start with American music in
the ,20s. It would help if you knew about Irish and Celtic music
as well. American music is essentially a
nuclear fusion of blues and country. That's what the whole
thing's about. Nothing else matters. You have to
know the history of it, which doesn't involve listening to Otis
Rush just once. It doesn't involve listening to
Speckled Red once. It doesn't involve listening to Gid Tanner And
The Skillet Lickers once. It doesn't
involve listening to Bob Wills once. It's extremely foolish to
have all these music schools create opportunities
for talented kids to learn how to do technical things
unbelievably well, when they don't understand where the
hell it's coming from. Lots of people play music and don’t
really hear it, which brings us to the subject of
musical musicians and unmusical musicians. There are many
impressive players who are far more technically
adept than I am, for instance, but they're not hearing it,
they're just doing it. Sticking stuff in the right boxes,
depending on what the progression is.
So what's the antidote?
Be concerned with the soul quotient of your music, the sheer joy
of being in the heart of something. And don't
be concerned about the marketplace. The music business is
something that's completely and utterly separate
from music. Don't think about singles. Just do what the hell you
really want to do. Learn to hear music, so
whatever is going on, you find a way to help it. Finding Parts is
a musical musician's speciality: Parts are what
make great records - not producers. It's not a question of what
you know. It all comes down to this: What
are you prepared to give of yourself?